The Book

Great Books

« Put Your Favorite Guru To the Test | Main | New GMO Market Forecasts: Stock Investors Are Screwed »

Meet Your Competition: Deep Blue

One of the most pointless and misleading topics of conversation for amateur traders is the idea of a "level playing field."  Cynical amateur traders believe that the reason they lose to professionals is that professionals have "inside information" and other illegal advantages. 

Professionals do indeed have significant advantages, information and other, but most of them are perfectly legal.  Professionals routinely beat the stuffing out of amateurs not because the playing field isn't level but because the playing field's being level or not is irrelevant

The playing field in Yankee Stadium is "level."  If you and your beer-league softball buddies visited the Bronx, however, you would still get your clocks cleaned--and not because not because the Yankees cheated.  You would get them cleaned because the Yankees are the most skilled, best informed, best trained, most competitive ballplayers on earth.  And so it goes in the financial markets.

Today's Journal has an illustrative item about the computerized trading taking over the London futures markets.  Like your chances of competing against thousands of professional futures traders armed with such computers?  Then presumably you would also like your chances when playing chess against Deep Blue.

Futures Traders Take On Next Hot Model

By ADAM BRADBERY
February 19, 2007

LONDON -- The biggest trader in one of Europe's main futures contracts isn't a person -- it is a machine. So is the second. And the third.

Trading systems that use complex mathematical codes to quickly weigh a huge number of possible trades and execute them faster than a human are squeezing the independent trader as they change the way futures contracts are traded...

 

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/2015756/16242040

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Meet Your Competition: Deep Blue:

Comments

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Real Investment Gurus

  • TERRANCE ODEAN
    Expert in behavioral finance: the dumb mistakes we make and why.
  • EUGENE FAMA
    Showed that most investment performance has nothing to do with traditional "stockpicking."
  • KENNETH FRENCH
    Dartmouth professor, Fama co-author, and advisor to Dimensional Fund Advisors, which offers intelligently designed (and top-performing) passive funds.
  • ROBERT J. SHILLER
    King of mean-reversion: Sooner or later, markets (stocks or housing) revert to long-term averages. Developed a defensible and predictive valuation tool: the cyclically adjusted PE.
  • JEREMY SIEGEL
    Fame may have gone to head (refers to HIMSELF as "Wizard of Wharton"), but author of excellent books and editorials. Advises WisdomTree, which offers intelligently designed, passive ETFs.
  • JEREMY GRANTHAM
    Manages $100-billion-plus at GMO. Always wise, often funny, occasionally wrong, never in doubt.
  • ANDREW SMITHERS
    Smart, independent strategist. His research costs arm and leg, but occasionally writes for masses (see "Newsroom"). Current view? We're screwed.
  • PAUL KASRIEL
    Northern Trust economist. Writes antidotes to typical "good times will keep rolling" pablum. Colleague Asha Bangalore smart, too.
  • MICHAEL MAUBOUSSIN
    Smart, cross-disciplinary thinker who doesn't waste time predicting future, making trading calls, or being mostly bullish. Identifies what smart investors do that others don't.
  • JOHN BOGLE
    Founder of Vanguard and true hero for small investors. Appalled by the billions the investment industry pays itself each year for subtracting value. Has arguably done more for small investors than anyone in history.
  • WARREN E. BUFFETT
    Of course, but note why: Few predictions, no market timing, no trading, no strategy drift, and favorite holding period of "forever." Also note how utterly different this is than frantic trading and predicting that usually passes for "smart investing."
  • JONATHAN CLEMENTS
    Columnist for WSJ ($). Continues to write about (boring) intelligent investing instead of sexier stock-picking, market-timing, etc., despite voluminous reader ridicule and hate mail.
  • BILL GROSS
    PIMCO bond king. Commanding knowledge of long-term economic and market fundamentals.